I found my favorite private detective, Spenser, decades ago, brought to life by Robert B. Parker. In addition to the Spenser novels, Parker also created the interconnected Sunny Randall and Jesse Stone novels.

Recently fans of Robert B. Parker’s enduring literary world have been treated to two fresh takes on his beloved characters: Buzzkill by Alison Gaylin, a Sunny Randall novel, and Hot Property by Mike Lupica, a Spenser series entry. While both novels honor Parker’s legacy, they offer distinct experiences that merit comparison. Here’s a deep dive into each book and its author.

---

Buzzkill by Alison Gaylin

Alison Gaylin, a celebrated crime novelist, brings a compelling voice to the Sunny Randall series with Buzzkill. Known for her Edgar Award-winning and bestselling works such as If I Die Tonight and Never Look Back, Gaylin demonstrates her expertise in crafting complex, emotionally charged mysteries.

In Buzzkill, Sunny Randall is hired to investigate a potentially dangerous stalker, but the case quickly spirals into a tangled web of lies, obsession, and murder. Gaylin masterfully weaves themes of vulnerability and empowerment, making Sunny’s journey resonate on a deeply human level. The pacing is tight, the dialogue sharp, and the plot layered with unexpected twists that keep readers on edge.

Gaylin’s ability to delve into Sunny’s psyche sets this book apart. While maintaining Parker’s hallmark wit and crisp prose, she injects a depth that feels refreshingly modern. Buzzkill doesn’t just entertain; it also explores the nuances of Sunny’s personal growth, making it a standout in the series.

---

Hot Property by Mike Lupica

Mike Lupica is no stranger to Parker’s universe, having written multiple Spenser novels that capture the grit and charm of the iconic private investigator. Lupica’s reputation precedes him as a prolific author of sports fiction (Heat, Travel Team) and adult thrillers (Dead Air). His familiarity with Parker’s style is evident in Hot Property, where Spenser navigates the murky world of real estate scams and murder.

Lupica’s Hot Property delivers a solid mystery with all the hallmarks of the Spenser series: snappy banter, action-packed scenes, and Spenser’s unwavering moral compass. However, while enjoyable, the novel doesn’t reach the heights of the series’ best entries. The plot, though engaging, feels somewhat formulaic, and the supporting characters don’t leave a lasting impression.

That said, a three-star Spenser novel is still better than many five-star mysteries. Lupica’s respect for Parker’s legacy shines through, and fans will appreciate the familiar rhythms and Spenser’s enduring charisma.

---

Head-to-Head Comparison

When comparing Buzzkill and Hot Property, Gaylin’s Sunny Randall novel emerges as the stronger novel. While both books deliver satisfying mysteries, Buzzkill excels in character development and emotional resonance. Sunny’s investigation feels personal and urgent, while Spenser’s case, though entertaining, lacks the same depth and freshness.

Gaylin’s prose captures Parker’s spirit while adding her unique flair, making Buzzkill a must-read for fans of the Sunny Randall series and crime fiction in general. Lupica’s Hot Property is a solid addition to the Spenser canon, and a novel all die-hard fans of the series will enjoy.

---

Author Spotlights

Alison Gaylin

• Edgar Award-winning author.
• Known for psychological thrillers such as If I Die Tonight and Never Look Back.
• Renowned for her intricate plotting and emotionally resonant storytelling.

Mike Lupica

• A prolific author of sports-themed fiction (Heat, Travel Team) and thrillers (Dead Air).
• A seasoned writer in Parker’s universe, continuing the Spenser series with several well-received novels.
• Praised for his snappy dialogue and action-driven plots.

---